[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":104},["ShallowReactive",2],{"\u002Fblog\u002F2021-12-16-why-the-marketplace-priced-nfts-in-matic":3},{"id":4,"title":5,"archiveType":6,"body":7,"category":88,"contextDate":89,"cover":90,"coverAlt":91,"date":92,"description":93,"extension":94,"featured":95,"historicalDate":92,"historicalLabel":89,"meta":96,"navigation":97,"path":98,"publishedDate":89,"seo":99,"stem":100,"thumbnail":89,"workPeriod":101,"writtenDate":102,"__hash__":103},"blogs\u002Fblog\u002F2021-12-16-why-the-marketplace-priced-nfts-in-matic.md","Why the marketplace priced NFTs in MATIC, not our own token","retrospective",{"type":8,"value":9,"toc":79},"minimark",[10,22,25,30,33,36,39,43,46,50,53,56,60,63,66,69,73,76],[11,12,13,14,21],"p",{},"December 2021 was the month Playermon NFTs began to move between players. The Genesis egg sale ran from 3 to 6 December, and buying an egg required PYM, our own token. Hatching opened on 20 December. In between, on 15 December, our own marketplace ",[15,16,20],"a",{"href":17,"rel":18},"https:\u002F\u002Ft.me\u002Fplayermon\u002F734",[19],"nofollow","opened for trading",".",[11,23,24],{},"The marketplace prices Playermons and eggs in MATIC, the native token of Polygon, and not in PYM. We had presented PYM as the game's payment token, so the choice needed explaining. On 16 December I posted an announcement as CEO explaining the decision, which the team had reached after deliberation. This post sets out that reasoning in more detail, including the part that does not favour PYM holders.",[26,27,29],"h2",{"id":28},"every-player-already-holds-matic","Every player already holds MATIC",[11,31,32],{},"On Polygon, every transaction pays gas in MATIC. Hatching an egg needs MATIC, and so does moving an NFT. Anyone who has hatched an egg or moved an NFT on Polygon has already had to hold MATIC.",[11,34,35],{},"PYM is different. A player holds it only if they have already acquired it.",[11,37,38],{},"The announcement put this as an easier entry. The decision lets us expand Playermon and encourage more people to join, because the first purchase uses a token the player already holds.",[26,40,42],{"id":41},"where-the-fees-go","Where the fees go",[11,44,45],{},"The marketplace collects transaction fees, and the announcement said those fees would fund marketing campaigns. The currency matters here. If fees arrived in PYM, paying for marketing would mean selling PYM on the open market, again and again. The team would become a regular seller of its own token. Collecting fees in MATIC avoids that. In the announcement's words, it avoids \"the dumping of PYM in the process\".",[26,47,49],{"id":48},"what-sellers-get-and-what-they-do-not","What sellers get, and what they do not",[11,51,52],{},"A listing priced in PYM ties the NFT's price to PYM's price. The seller would carry two exposures at once, one to the Playermon market and one to our token. Pricing in MATIC removes the second.",[11,54,55],{},"It does not remove volatility. MATIC is not a stablecoin, and its price moves too. What changes is that a seller's price no longer depends on the token whose supply and demand our own decisions influence most directly. We also do not set prices for them. When people asked whether there would be a floor price for eggs on the marketplace, our answer was that the community would set it.",[26,57,59],{"id":58},"the-trade-off-for-pym-holders","The trade-off for PYM holders",[11,61,62],{},"The cost is easy to state. Marketplace purchases do not require anyone to buy PYM. A source of demand that holders might reasonably have expected is not there.",[11,64,65],{},"The case for accepting that cost is that a token's demand should come from what it does in the game, not from a toll on every purchase. The announcement listed those uses: breeding Playermons, buying items to craft new items, building and upgrading Space Den, exploring dungeons on the open-world planet, expanding colonial bases with community-built decorations, and letting creators mint their own game assets. Pushing every buyer through a swap would raise demand only as long as people kept buying, and it would make the first experience of the game a trip to a decentralised exchange.",[11,67,68],{},"The weakness of that case is timing. The announcement describes most of those uses in the future tense. At the end of December, players were earning in-game points in SpaceDen, and claiming SGEM was scheduled to start on 5 January. Breeding and crafting were still ahead of us. Until they arrive, PYM holders are being asked to accept a cost now for demand that comes later, and that request is only reasonable if we deliver.",[26,70,72],{"id":71},"the-month-around-it","The month around it",[11,74,75],{},"SpaceDen went live on 22 December, the first playable part of the game, and the team was clear that it is an open beta built to collect feedback. A video AMA I did with BCA was published on 17 December, and I took questions in our own Telegram group on 22 December. Meanwhile the CertiK audit was still in progress, with an update on 24 December.",[11,77,78],{},"The marketplace decision is the one that needs the most explaining. I think it is the right call for getting new players in. Whether it is the right call for PYM depends on how quickly the game gives the token work to do.",{"title":80,"searchDepth":81,"depth":81,"links":82},"",2,[83,84,85,86,87],{"id":28,"depth":81,"text":29},{"id":41,"depth":81,"text":42},{"id":48,"depth":81,"text":49},{"id":58,"depth":81,"text":59},{"id":71,"depth":81,"text":72},"DeFi",null,"\u002Fimg\u002Fblog-covers\u002F2021-12-16-why-the-marketplace-priced-nfts-in-matic.webp","A collectible card with a blank price tag, a blue coin on the tag and a yellow coin set aside.","2021-12-16","December 2021: Playermon's own marketplace opened with prices in MATIC rather than PYM. The reasons we gave, what they mean for sellers, and the trade-off for token holders.","md",false,{},true,"\u002Fblog\u002F2021-12-16-why-the-marketplace-priced-nfts-in-matic",{"title":5,"description":93},"blog\u002F2021-12-16-why-the-marketplace-priced-nfts-in-matic","2021","2026-11-07","lFnfrtAy7wvYDEm7wrc9hHiOKb0QwRwxBuTocq4mSJA",1794838285787]