[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":110},["ShallowReactive",2],{"\u002Fblog\u002F2023-02-17-what-gamefi-2-would-have-to-mean":3},{"id":4,"title":5,"archiveType":6,"body":7,"category":94,"contextDate":95,"cover":96,"coverAlt":97,"date":98,"description":99,"extension":100,"featured":101,"historicalDate":98,"historicalLabel":95,"meta":102,"navigation":103,"path":104,"publishedDate":95,"seo":105,"stem":106,"thumbnail":95,"workPeriod":107,"writtenDate":108,"__hash__":109},"blogs\u002Fblog\u002F2023-02-17-what-gamefi-2-would-have-to-mean.md","What “GameFi 2.0” would have to mean","retrospective",{"type":8,"value":9,"toc":85},"minimark",[10,22,25,30,33,36,39,43,46,49,53,56,59,62,65,69,72,75,79,82],[11,12,13,14,21],"p",{},"On 17 February I sat on a panel at ",[15,16,20],"a",{"href":17,"rel":18},"https:\u002F\u002Fanndy.com\u002Fevent\u002Fcrypto-industry-key-topics-to-be-explored-at-blockchain-fest-singapore\u002F",[19],"nofollow","Blockchain Fest Singapore",", at Marina Bay Sands, titled \"GameFi 2.0 | The Next Big Thing in Crypto?\". I went as CEO of Playermon, and it was also a chance to introduce the game to an audience in Singapore.",[11,23,24],{},"The question mark in that title earns its place. This post is not a record of what anyone said on stage. It is my own answer, written down afterwards, to what a second generation of blockchain games would have to change.",[26,27,29],"h2",{"id":28},"what-the-first-version-taught","What the first version taught",[11,31,32],{},"The pitch for play-to-earn in 2021 was simple: play a game, earn a token. In 2022 the market tested that pitch hard. Terra collapsed in May and FTX in November, and confidence drained from everything near crypto, game tokens included.",[11,34,35],{},"When the reward is the main reason to play, a falling token removes the reason. Players who came for the earning leave when the earning shrinks. The ones who stay can find that the game was built around a payout rather than around play.",[11,37,38],{},"In October 2021, soon after I became CEO, I described what we were aiming for like this: \"We try to strike a balance now between having fun and earning.\" I still hold to that sentence. What has changed is how strictly I read the order of its two halves.",[26,40,42],{"id":41},"the-game-has-to-come-first","The game has to come first",[11,44,45],{},"A 2.0 game is one people would play on a day when its token was worth nothing. That is a design test, not a slogan. It means the work that matters most is the work a player sees in a battle.",[11,47,48],{},"On 1 February we released patch 2.6.0, which brought buff and debuff skill cards and passive skills into PvE battles. Cards and passives can now raise or lower six attributes on a Playermon, its teammates or an enemy: current health, maximum health, shield, intelligence, agility and luck. None of that touches the token. It turns a battle into a series of decisions instead of a sequence of clicks, and that is the kind of change I want most of our roadmap to be made of.",[26,50,52],{"id":51},"rewards-need-a-budget","Rewards need a budget",[11,54,55],{},"The second requirement is that rewards come from a budget that someone can read. In the first wave, token emissions often ran ahead of any plan for what would absorb them.",[11,57,58],{},"Our Anchorland leaderboard season works the other way round. Season 2 paid a published table of PYM to the top 50 players, and the rewards went out at the turn of January and February in a single on-chain transaction that anyone can look up on Polygonscan. The rules also said what would not be rewarded: moving NFTs between wallets to manipulate the leaderboard leads to disqualification.",[11,60,61],{},"A fixed table does not make a reward sustainable on its own. It makes the cost visible, which is the first step towards deciding whether a game can afford it. The rest is design. Rewards should go to play that is hard to automate, and what a player can earn should not depend on a steady flow of new buyers.",[11,63,64],{},"The team carries part of this too. Our own PYM allocation vests over ten years, a schedule I set out publicly in January 2022. People who build a game should be paid over the same horizon they ask their players to stay for.",[26,66,68],{"id":67},"a-way-in-without-a-wallet","A way in without a wallet",[11,70,71],{},"The third requirement is the hardest one for a blockchain game to accept. Most games in this space still ask a newcomer to install a wallet, write down a seed phrase and buy something before the first battle. Each step loses people, and the seed phrase hands a serious responsibility to someone who only wanted to try a game.",[11,73,74],{},"A 2.0 game would let someone play first and decide afterwards whether they want to own anything on-chain. Ownership should be a feature for the players who want it, not a gate in front of everyone.",[26,76,78],{"id":77},"what-i-would-not-call-20","What I would not call 2.0",[11,80,81],{},"A new token is not 2.0. Neither is a new chain, or a new name for the same loop of buying in and selling out. The test I keep coming back to is simple to state and hard to pass: if the token disappeared tomorrow, would the game still have players?",[11,83,84],{},"That is the standard I am holding our own work to this year. It asks more of the game designers than of the token designers, which is the right way round.",{"title":86,"searchDepth":87,"depth":87,"links":88},"",2,[89,90,91,92,93],{"id":28,"depth":87,"text":29},{"id":41,"depth":87,"text":42},{"id":51,"depth":87,"text":52},{"id":67,"depth":87,"text":68},{"id":77,"depth":87,"text":78},"Gaming",null,"\u002Fimg\u002Fblog-covers\u002F2023-02-17-what-gamefi-2-would-have-to-mean.webp","A game controller in front, a small blue coin purse behind it and an open door frame beside them.","2023-02-17","After a GameFi 2.0 panel at Blockchain Fest Singapore, my own answer to what the next round of blockchain games has to change: the game first, rewards with a budget, and a way in without a wallet.","md",false,{},true,"\u002Fblog\u002F2023-02-17-what-gamefi-2-would-have-to-mean",{"title":5,"description":99},"blog\u002F2023-02-17-what-gamefi-2-would-have-to-mean","2023","2026-11-07","1vHhaIo9aNR-LpJeKtRGLqhTdcB377X4WKL4EZW3Kb4",1794838285736]