All field notes

Leadership · Retrospective

Putting a giveaway to a token-holder vote after bots gamed it

A ballot box with a gift box on top, a small robot figure held back behind a low barrier.
Concept illustration · AI-generated

On 27 May I published Playermon's first DAO proposal. It asks PYM holders to decide what happens to the 1.5 Million Giveaway, the referral campaign we launched on 24 February. Voting runs from 1 to 8 June at dao.playermon.com. This post is about why the decision went to holders rather than staying with the team, and how the rules of the vote were set.

What went wrong

The giveaway rewarded referrals, and a referral leaderboard rewards whoever can produce the most accounts. Suspected fake referral bots climbed to the top of ours, above genuine players. On 29 March we apologised publicly and said we were filtering and banning bot accounts. The team removed most of them using several techniques, but removing every last one would be difficult and very time-consuming, and any winners list we published would carry that doubt. On 14 May we told the community a vote was coming.

Why not decide it ourselves

The team could have cancelled the giveaway, or paid it out after another round of filtering. Both were within our authority. We put it to holders instead, for three reasons.

Conditions changed after launch. From 7 May, Terra's UST lost its dollar peg and LUNA collapsed with it, and the whole market felt the shock. The proposal says directly that we wanted to protect the community's investment in a bear market, and that a giveaway of this size would put heavy pressure on it in these conditions. That pressure would be felt by everyone holding PYM, not only by the giveaway's winners.

The people who carry the cost should weigh it. Holders are the ones who would feel that pressure, so holders should be the ones to set it against the promise we made to participants.

And no answer satisfies everyone. Genuine referrers did real work and expect to be rewarded for it. Not everyone in the community liked the giveaway in the first place. A decision announced by the team would leave one group feeling overruled. A vote with published rules makes the trade-off visible and lets the community own the result.

Three options, not two

Holders can vote to cancel the giveaway, to continue it, or to cancel it but allocate a smaller amount as compensation to the top referrers once the bots are removed. The third option is there because a straight cancellation would punish genuine referrers for what the bots did, and a straight continuation would ask everyone to trust a list we cannot fully clean.

How the snapshot rules were set

The rules are short, and each one closes a specific gap:

  • Every PYM held in a wallet, or staked in the Breeding Pod Shard PYM pool, counts as one vote. Staked tokens count, so nobody has to unstake to be heard.
  • Voting spends nothing. A voter connects a wallet and signs a message, and we check it against balances on the blockchain at the snapshot block height.
  • PYM bought after the snapshot does not count.

That last rule matters more after April. On 17 April, Beanstalk was drained by an attacker who used a flash loan to borrow enough voting power to pass a malicious proposal and execute it in a single transaction. Fixing balances at a block that has already passed means voting power cannot be borrowed for the vote, and nobody can buy a result after reading the question. Because votes are signed messages, the vote moves no funds by itself either.

No rule removes every weakness. Token weighting gives larger holders more say, and turnout is never complete. But a bot with no PYM has no vote, which is exactly the problem the referral leaderboard could not solve. A referral counts accounts, which are cheap to fake. A snapshot counts tokens held before the question was asked, which are not.

What it commits the team to

The proposal calls this the beginning of DAO voting at Playermon, with more proposals to come, from roadmap priorities to the name of an enemy in the game. For me as CEO, putting a decision to holders means accepting an outcome I might not have picked, and then carrying it out without reopening it. That is the part of governance that has nothing to do with code.

It also changes how I think about campaigns. A giveaway is a promise, and a promise made to a leaderboard is only as good as the leaderboard. The next time we design a reward, the first question will be what it counts, and how cheaply someone could fake it.