Security · Retrospective
Season rules that bots cannot cheaply farm

On 30 September the Anchorland alpha closed and our PvE story mode went into beta. On 14 October our channel pointed players to a video on how to play the beta and get onto its leaderboard. A leaderboard that pays out in tokens is a target, so the rules for the beta season were published with the news that the alpha had closed, a few hours before the beta went live and before anyone had a score in it.
This month I want to set out why those rules look the way they do.
What bots taught us this year
Two incidents this year shaped them. In March, bots went after one of our giveaways. In May, suspected fake referral accounts sat at the top of the referral leaderboard for the 1.5 Million Giveaway instead of genuine players. The team filtered out most of them, but, as I wrote when we put that giveaway to a token-holder vote, removing every bot would have been difficult and very slow.
Both incidents had the same shape. The reward was paid for an action, and the action cost a script almost nothing: an entry, a referral, a new account. When a reward is attached to something that is free to repeat, the people best placed to collect it are the ones who can repeat it fastest.
What the beta rules say
The rules for the Anchorland beta are short:
- The leaderboard is rewarded at the end of a season, not for each level completed.
- The leaderboard is reset and rewarded whenever new skills or a major game update arrive, and players then rechallenge the earlier levels.
- An account needs at least three Playermon NFTs at the snapshot taken when the season ends.
- Manipulation is not rewarded.
The alpha already used a version of the third rule. Its top 50 players qualified for rewards only if their accounts held at least three Playermon NFTs before the maintenance window on 30 September.
Why seasons instead of levels
Paying for each level completed puts a price on every clear, and a script can collect that price as often as it can clear the level. Paying by rank at the end of a season turns the reward into a competition. A bot can no longer earn by repetition. It has to beat the strongest human players across a whole season, with teams and skill cards that change between updates.
Resetting on major updates helps for a second reason. When new skills change how a fight plays out, old scores stop measuring the same thing. A reset also limits how long any lead built on one version of the game can last. In our Q3 update we said we would ship smaller updates more often, so that the leaderboard refreshes more often and rewards the players who are active now.
Why three NFTs
An account costs nothing to create. An account that can be paid needs three Playermons in it. A farm of a hundred accounts therefore needs three hundred Playermons, which is a very different proposition from a hundred empty accounts.
That does not make farming impossible. It makes each extra account cost roughly what a real player's team costs, which is the price I want anyone gaming the board to face. It also ties the leaderboard to the game's own assets: the accounts that can be paid are accounts that hold a team.
What a snapshot still misses
A snapshot checks one moment. It shows that an account held three Playermons when the season closed. On its own, it cannot show whether the same NFTs were moved between wallets during the season so that one set served several accounts.
"Manipulation is not rewarded" is the rule that covers that gap, and it only works if we look for it. I would rather write a broad rule and enforce it carefully than pretend that a single on-chain check settles every case.
Rules before the season, not after
The order matters as much as the content. If eligibility rules appear only when the payout is due, every disqualification looks like a team choosing its winners. Published before the season, they are a condition everyone accepted by playing.
The wider industry gave a sharp example this month. On 11 October someone pushed up the price of Mango Markets' own token on thin markets and borrowed heavily against the inflated position. A few days later the person behind it argued in public that he had only used the protocol as designed. Whatever one makes of that argument, it shows what happens when the written mechanics are the only rules: anything they permit gets treated as fair. A game leaderboard is much smaller, but the principle holds. Say plainly what the reward is for, and what it is not for, before the first score is posted.
The other kind of farming
Prizes also attract impersonators. On 11 October we warned the community about fake accounts using our name, reminded everyone that no airdrop or whitelist was running, and repeated the basics: never give out your seed phrase, never send money when you are unsure, and always check. A season with real rewards gives scammers a story to tell, so the warning belongs alongside the rules, not after the first loss.