DeFi · Retrospective
Giving the game currency somewhere to go

Playermon runs on two tokens. PYM is the governance token: it pays for the larger purchases, such as Genesis Eggs, it is meant to pay for breeding when that arrives, and our DAO votes are weighted by the PYM a wallet holds or stakes. SGEM is the currency players earn by playing, for example by completing quests in SpaceDen. The two were designed to do different jobs.
This quarter we started connecting them. On 10 June we published a set of changes to how PYM and SGEM work together:
- a controlled burn to reduce the supply of SGEM;
- moving part of the USDT in the SGEM-USDT liquidity pool into the PYM pool;
- new craftable items, so that SGEM has uses beyond buying and selling;
- moving the Breeding Pod from ERC-721 to the ERC-1155 standard.
The post promises craftable items without yet saying what they are. The most direct way to give SGEM somewhere to go would be a recipe that links the two tokens: SGEM in, PYM or an egg out.
That kind of recipe is the part I want to think through before it ships: a conversion between two tokens is a monetary decision that looks like a game feature.
Why SGEM needed somewhere to go
A currency earned by playing keeps arriving whether or not there is anything to spend it on. Inside the game SGEM already had some uses. Since April it buys extra energy for Adventure Mode. Outside the game, the main thing a player could do with SGEM was sell it into the SGEM-USDT pool, and every sale there lowers the price for everyone still earning it.
That is the usual trap for a reward currency. If selling is the only exit, the players who earn the most also push hardest on the price of what they earn.
What a one-way recipe does
Crafting runs in one direction. The SGEM a player puts into a recipe would be used up, and PYM or an egg would come out. Nothing would turn PYM back into SGEM.
For SGEM, every craft would be a sink. From the player's side, SGEM spent on a recipe is gone: it is no longer waiting to be sold into the pool. That would work alongside the controlled burn.
For PYM, every craft would be a payout. PYM that comes out of a recipe adds to the PYM in players' hands, in the same way that leaderboard prizes paid in PYM do. A recipe that pays out PYM has a cost, even though nobody sees an invoice for it.
The liquidity change points the same way. With part of the USDT moved from the SGEM pool to the PYM pool, the SGEM pool is thinner and the PYM pool deeper. With a conversion recipe, a holder who wants to leave SGEM would have a second route, and that route would end in the deeper pool.
The egg recipe needs its own paragraph. When Genesis Eggs went on sale in 2021 they were bought with PYM, and the sale was designed to burn PYM for each egg. An egg crafted from SGEM would be a new Playermon entering the collection, paid for with play rather than with PYM. That would make an egg recipe a decision about the NFT collection as much as about the currency.
Why the rate is a governance question
Every such recipe would have a rate: how much SGEM, or SGEM and shards, buys one PYM or one egg. It is tempting to treat that number as a balance setting, like the cost of energy. I do not think it is one.
PYM is the token our votes are weighted by. A recipe that turns SGEM into PYM is, in effect, a way of turning hours of play into voting weight. Set the rate generously and active players gain PYM faster, and with it a larger share of every vote. Set it tightly and SGEM is worth less to the people who earn it, and the sink does little.
Neither setting is wrong. They favour different groups: the players who earn SGEM, and the holders whose share of PYM shrinks a little with every unit a recipe pays out. Questions like that, where the answer is a choice between groups rather than something we can test, are what token-holder votes are for.
The team has to choose a starting rate to ship the feature at all. After that, I would want any change announced before it takes effect, with the reasoning written out, because a rate change without notice moves value from one group to another overnight.
What a studio actually controls
The month closed with patch 2.9.0 on 26 June, which added five new Anchorland levels and lets a new player claim up to five free starter Playermons. More players starting for free means more SGEM being earned.
June was also the month the SEC sued Binance and Coinbase. Neither case involves us, but it was a reminder of how little of a token's market a game studio controls. We do not control the exchanges or the wider market. We control our own pools, our own sinks, our own recipes and the rates written into them. Those are the levers worth getting right.