Leadership · Retrospective
Which decisions belong to designers and which to token holders

On 9 July we published DAO Proposal #2, on the rewards for the Anchorland leaderboard. PYM holders voted on it from 14 to 17 July through our Snapshot page at dao.playermon.com. The same document also told players, without asking them, that the leaderboard would now reset on the 5th of every month.
One page, two kinds of decision. I think the split was right, and this month gave me a reason to write down why.
What went to the vote
The proposal offered three reward tables, each with its monthly total:
- keep the current rewards: 50,000 PYM for first place, down to 3,000 PYM each for 21st to 50th, 292,500 PYM in all;
- keep those and add 1,000 PYM each for 51st to 300th, 542,500 PYM in all;
- raise the rewards for the top 50 and add places 51st to 100th, 574,000 PYM in all.
Voting weight came from PYM, counting both PYM held in a wallet on Polygon and PYM staked with us. When the vote closed, holders had chosen to keep the current rewards, with just over half of the voting weight.
What did not go to a vote
The switch to a monthly, time-based leaderboard after season four ended on 5 July was the team's call, announced before the vote. So were most of the changes players noticed this year. Our Q2 recap, published on 10 July, lists them: an energy system, so that players could no longer restart again and again until they drew good starting cards; all three starter Playermons granted for verifying an email; the love-rank requirement for SpaceDen decorations removed; 23 skill cards rebalanced.
The starter and decoration changes were direct responses to player feedback. None of the four was voted on.
Where I draw the line
Holders decide how value is shared. The leaderboard question was about how much PYM goes out each month and how far down the table it reaches. There is no correct answer to that. It is a trade between the best players, who want the top prizes protected; the middle of the table, who want a chance at something; and holders, who pay for every extra place through the PYM it puts into circulation. When the answer depends on whose interest you weigh, the people with a stake should do the weighing.
Designers decide what can be tested. Whether a skill card is too strong, whether a level is too hard, whether restarts distort a season: these have answers we can find in play and in player reports, and players need them quickly. This proposal took eight days from publication to result. A vote also has a worse problem for balance questions: a vote on a card's numbers would be won by whoever holds the most of that card.
Abuse does not wait for a vote. When bots abused a referral leaderboard in 2022, stopping the abuse was our job, not a question for a vote. Whether to go ahead with the giveaway it fed was a fair question for holders, and it became our first proposal, in May 2022.
The menu is the team's responsibility
A vote among three options is only as fair as the options. We wrote all three, and every one kept the top 50 paid. Holders chose how far down the table to go and how much to spend, not whether the leaderboard should pay out at all. That framing was a design decision, and I would rather say so openly than present the vote as wider than it was.
Writing the total next to each option mattered too. "Reward more players" sounds free until the proposal says it costs 250,000 PYM a month more than the current table.
Who is not in the room
Votes are weighted by PYM. After this year's changes, a new player can start with free starter Playermons and play without holding any PYM at all. Those players have no vote, and decisions about difficulty, energy and balance affect them more than anyone.
That is the strongest reason I see for keeping gameplay decisions with the designers. Someone has to answer for the players who are not holders, and a token-weighted vote cannot.
The test I use is short. If a decision has an answer we can measure, it is ours, and we explain it. If it is a choice between groups' interests, it goes to holders, with the options and their costs written out.
Later in the month, our cross-promotion with Genso had me scheduled as the guest on a Twitter Spaces AMA on 26 July.