All field notes

DeFi · Retrospective

Paying leaderboard rewards in the game currency instead of the token

A three-step podium with yellow coins on each step.
Concept illustration · AI-generated

From Season 9, the top players on Playermon's Anchorland leaderboard stopped receiving PYM, our token, and started receiving SGEM, the game's own currency, claimed inside the game. The change came from a community vote and shipped in patch 2.10.0 on 20 November. It is one line in the patch notes, and one of the more consequential economic decisions we have made this year.

What the vote offered

DAO Proposal #4 opened at the end of October, with voting from 30 October to 4 November. It offered four ways to fund the leaderboard, which pays the top 50 players in tiers:

  • 292,500 PYM once a month;
  • 585,000 SGEM once a month;
  • 292,500 SGEM every 14 days;
  • 150,000 SGEM every week.

On 6 November we announced the result: 53.48% of the vote went to the third option, SGEM every 14 days. The next day the last PYM rewards, for Season 8, went out as an on-chain transfer, and the leaderboard moved to a fortnightly cycle with payouts every second Monday.

The three SGEM options paid out a similar total over a month. The real choices on the ballot were the currency and the rhythm.

Why move the reward into the game

The proposal gave practical reasons. PYM rewards had to be distributed by hand, which is slow and invites mistakes. SGEM could be credited inside the game, so winners claim at once and can spend it without waiting for a transfer.

The economic reason matters more to me. A token paid to a leaderboard leaves the game the moment it lands. The winner holds a liquid asset with a market price, and the simplest thing to do with it is sell. Every season, our treasury sent a predictable amount of liquid token into players' wallets, whatever the game itself was doing.

SGEM paid inside the game lands where it has uses. Players spend it on energy for PvE levels and on crafting, and since June it can be crafted into PYM. A winner who wants the token can still get it, but the route now goes through a recipe whose cost the game sets, and every conversion consumes SGEM. The reward stays in the game unless the player chooses to take it out, and the way out has a price.

What it does not fix

Paying in the game currency does not make a reward sustainable. It moves the pressure from one place to another.

  • SGEM needs sinks to match. A currency issued every fortnight to fifty players has to be spent at a similar rate, or its value inside the game falls. Energy, crafting and items are those sinks, and they need tuning as the game changes.
  • The crafting rate becomes an exchange rate. If SGEM converts into PYM, the recipe decides how much of the leaderboard's value can leave as token. Set it loosely and we are paying PYM again by another route. Set it too tightly and the reward feels like play money. That rate is a governance question as much as a design one.
  • Players who wanted the token have a longer path. For some winners the PYM payout was the point. They now receive a game currency first and decide later.

None of these are reasons to go back. They are what I will be watching now that the decision is made.

Paying more often

The fortnightly cycle matters as much as the currency. A monthly season gives early leaders room to coast and gives late joiners little reason to try. A two-week reset gives more players a realistic chance at the board, and it gives us twice as many points at which to see whether the reward is changing behaviour in ways we did not intend. If a reward level turns out to be wrong, we find out in two weeks rather than four.

It also changes what "claiming" means. Under the old system a winner waited for us to send tokens. From Season 9, the game tells winners they have a reward, shows what each season pays, and lets them claim it themselves. That removes a manual step on our side and a wait on theirs.

Where it stands

At the end of November, Anchorland rewards from Season 9 onwards are paid in SGEM and claimed in the game, and the fortnightly rhythm is running. The vote settled the currency and the cadence. Whether SGEM's sinks keep pace with what the leaderboard issues is the question for the seasons ahead.