All field notes

Gaming · Retrospective

Opening PvP to testers before rewards are attached

An empty trophy cup half covered by a cloth, beside a game controller.
Concept illustration · AI-generated

On 19 January we opened Playermon's PvP for testing. Registration and testing were open for one week. The announcement offered no prizes. It asked for one thing: feedback.

Player-versus-player has been part of Playermon's plan from the start. When we first described SGEM, the game currency, in our 2021 AMAs, PvP battles were listed among the ways to earn it. So the question this month was not whether PvP will pay. It was what we needed to learn before it does.

Why test without rewards

When a mode starts paying, the people playing it change, and so does how they play. Some look for the quickest fair route to the reward. Some look for an unfair one. Friends trading wins, accounts that exist only to farm, and bots all appear for the same reason: the reward is worth more than the effort of gaming it. Those problems need their own rules. They also drown out the first thing we need to know, which is whether the mode is any good.

A test with nothing to win removes most of that noise. Someone who registers for a week of unpaid PvP mostly wants to play PvP. What they tell us is about the game: whether matches feel fair, whether they last a sensible length, and whether one team beats everything.

What PvE cannot tell us

Anchorland, our PvE adventure mode, has paid leaderboard rewards season after season, in SGEM since November. It teaches players the skill cards and how a Playermon's stats play out in a fight. But in PvE we design the opponent. Enemies grow stronger level by level, on a curve we chose.

In PvP the opponent is another player's best team. Each Playermon's skills come from its body parts, and players will find the combination of parts and skill cards that wins most often, then copy it. We rebalanced 23 skill cards last April. PvP is where any card that is still too strong will show itself, because now someone is looking for it on purpose.

What a closed test is for

A short, registered test has a narrow job.

  • Find dominant strategies early. If one build wins everything, it is far cheaper to learn that from testers than from a leaderboard with money on it.
  • Exercise the plumbing. Matchmaking, disconnections, timeouts, and what happens when one side stops playing. These failures are irritating in a test and expensive when a reward depends on the result.
  • Know who is testing. Registration ties feedback to accounts and to the matches they played, and keeps the group small enough to read every report.
  • Keep the window short. A week is long enough to see whether people come back for more matches, and short enough that nobody mistakes the test for the finished product.

What a closed test cannot do is predict how people behave once there is something to win. Anti-cheat measures and reward rules have to be designed as their own piece of work, and tested with real but limited stakes, before PvP results feed any reward.

The order matters

It is tempting to launch a competitive mode with rewards on the first day, because rewards bring players. I would rather attach them to a mode people already enjoy without them. If PvP is only worth playing when it pays, no reward design will hold it together for long. If people play it for the matches, a reward becomes a bonus we can tune, not the reason the mode exists.

That ordering is also kinder to the economy we spent last year adjusting. Every new source of SGEM or PYM needs a matching reason to spend it. Adding a reward to an untested mode would mean guessing both the issue rate and the behaviour at once. Testing first leaves us one unknown at a time.

Elsewhere this month

On 22 January Playermon announced that I will speak at Blockchain Festival Asia 2024 in Singapore, listed as Vice President of the Malaysia Blockchain Association and founder of TriveAcademy, as well as CEO of Playermon. Earlier in the month the team published guides on downloading SpaceDen and on trading Playermon NFTs on OpenSea and our Radix marketplace.