DeFi · Retrospective
Closing a liquidity pool and moving its rewards

On 26 February we published a short notice on the Playermon blog: the SGEM-USDT liquidity pool would stop receiving staking rewards, and its share would move to the two pools built around PYM. It is one of the less visible decisions a game studio makes. It still deserves a careful explanation, because rewards on a liquidity pool are a real cost and someone is always relying on them.
What we were running
At the start of the month the staking page offered three options:
- PYM staking, for holders who wanted to stake the token on its own.
- PYM-USDT LP, for people who supplied both tokens to the pair on Quickswap V2 and staked the LP tokens they received.
- SGEM-USDT LP, the same arrangement for SGEM, the in-game currency.
The staking contract paid out rewards every block and split them between the three pools by weight. Each pool's weight decided its share of every block.
What changed
The notice set out two steps. The interface would stop accepting new stakes into the SGEM-USDT LP pool while it handled the rewards still to be distributed there. The staking contract would be updated so that it stopped paying rewards to that pool's providers. The SGEM-USDT share of each block would then be divided between PYM staking and PYM-USDT LP in proportion to the weights they already had.
That last detail matters more than it looks. Proportional reallocation means both remaining pools grow by the same factor, so the balance between them does not move. We were not quietly favouring single-token stakers over liquidity providers, or the other way round. The only decision was to stop paying for one pool.
One thing we could not do, and it is worth saying plainly, is close the pair itself. A Quickswap V2 pair is a contract with no switch for a game studio to turn off. Anyone can still trade against it and anyone can still add liquidity to it. What we controlled was our own staking contract and our own interface. When a game announces that it is removing a pool, it is removing the incentive, not the market.
Why rewards should follow the liquidity the game needs
The published reason was simplicity: fewer options, and better rewards on the ones that remained. Behind that is the way I think about liquidity incentives in general.
A reward on a liquidity pool is a payment for depth. It buys a deeper market in one particular pair, and it comes out of the same budget as every other incentive in the game. So the question is not whether a pool is useful to someone. It usually is. The question is whether that pair is the one the game most needs to be deep.
By February, much of what a player did with SGEM happened inside the game. Anchorland leaderboard rewards were paid in SGEM and claimed in-game, and the table we posted on 6 February ran from 50,000 SGEM for the champion to 3,000 SGEM for places 21 to 50. Players topped up energy with SGEM in the middle of PvE. The Lunar New Year patch on 18 February added an extra 10 SGEM for taking part in Happy Hour. Most of SGEM's working life was in the game's own loops. Two of our three pools were already built around PYM, and concentrating the reward budget on them kept our incentives on the token itself.
That is not a claim that SGEM liquidity stopped mattering. Someone who wants to move between SGEM and USDT still needs a market, and the pair stayed open. It is a judgement about where a limited reward budget does the most for the game.
What a staker needs to be told
A change like this lands on people who have money in the pool. When I review a notice of this kind, I look for answers to four questions:
- Which pool is affected, and which are not?
- What happens to new deposits?
- What happens to rewards still owed?
- Where does the freed reward go, and by what rule?
Ours answered each of them. It named the pool, said new staking would stop, said the remaining rewards would be distributed, and described the reallocation rule.
The fact people check last is usually the one that matters most to them: their own position. A provider's LP tokens still represent a share of the SGEM-USDT pair. Only our reward on top of it stops. Saying that clearly is the difference between a pool being retired and a holder feeling that something was taken away.
The rest of the month
The pool change was a small part of February. Registered testers were playing the PvP alpha from 4 February, and the team published its recap of the last quarter of 2023 on 8 February. The staking change was the kind of housekeeping that is easy to postpone. I would rather do it while the reasons are fresh and the notice can be specific, than leave a pool drawing on the reward budget for depth the game no longer prioritises.