DeFi · Retrospective
Burning most of SGEM's supply while holders voted to widen rewards

Two things reached holders of SGEM, Playermon's in-game currency, in May: a vote to pay leaderboard rewards to more players, and the report on 26 May that recent burns had cut SGEM's supply from 19,454,142 to 3,960,981, so roughly four in every five SGEM had been removed. At first sight the two pull in opposite directions: one pays out more, the other takes tokens away. I think they belong together, and this post explains why, along with what a burn does not do.
The vote
On 4 May we published DAO Proposal #5, on Anchorland leaderboard rewards. The existing table paid the top 50 players each season, 292,500 SGEM in total, from 50,000 SGEM for first place down to 3,000 SGEM for places 21 to 50. The proposal argued that a table aimed at the very top gave newer and less experienced players little reason to compete. It offered four options: keep the table, extend it to the top 100, extend it to the top 100 with larger amounts at the top, or add rewards for places 51 to 300.
The voting snapshot was taken at 10:00 UTC on 6 May, two hours before voting opened, and voting closed on 9 May. Taking the snapshot before the vote opens means tokens bought during the vote carry no weight in it. On 10 May we announced the result: leaderboard rewards would reach the top 100, starting from Season 22. Every option that reached the top 100 paid out more than the old 292,500 SGEM a season.
The proposal also contained the sentence I cared about most. It committed us to analysing the effect of the extra SGEM on the game's economy, monitoring inflation, and adjusting the structure in later seasons if needed. A vote to spend more is only responsible when it comes with a commitment to watch what the spending does.
The burn
SGEM does several jobs in the game. It pays leaderboard rewards, it buys energy when a player runs low in the middle of PvE, and it rewards other in-game activity. Every SGEM in existence competes for the same set of things to spend it on. When supply runs far ahead of those uses, each new reward means less to the player who receives it.
When Bitdigest reported the burn on 26 May, I put the reason this way: "Our goal is to create a sustainable game economy, and the recent burns, combined with the expanded rewards program, are key steps towards achieving that."
The two halves of that sentence are the point. Widening rewards without reducing supply would have added more SGEM on top of a supply that was already large. Reducing supply without widening rewards would have tidied the numbers without giving more players a reason to compete. Together they change who receives new SGEM, towards a broader group of active players, from a much smaller base.
What a burn cannot fix
A burn changes the stock of a currency once. It does not change the flow. If each season pays out more SGEM than the game takes back through energy, crafting and its other uses, supply grows again, and the burn becomes a one-off reset rather than a fix.
So the numbers to watch are not the headline ones. They are what each season pays out against what players spend, season after season. That is why the monitoring commitment in Proposal #5 mattered more to me than the size of the burn.
A burn also cannot create demand. Fewer tokens do not give anyone a new reason to hold or use the ones that remain. Only the game can do that. The leaderboard that reaches the top 100 from Season 22, and the PvP mode the team shipped in April, belong in the same conversation as the supply figures. An economy is the game's activity measured in a currency, not the other way round.
Reporting it plainly
I would rather describe the burn with its limits than present it as an achievement. The supply figures are facts, and anyone can compare them. Whether the economy stays in balance is something only the coming seasons can show, and I am not going to claim it before they do. Until then, the work is the unglamorous part: watching payouts and spending season by season, and being ready to adjust the reward table, as the proposal committed us to, if the two drift apart.