Gaming · Retrospective
Soul-binding Playermons once breeding arrives

At the end of July we explained breeding on the Playermon blog: combining the traits of Playermons to create new ones. Like batch hatching and the new marketplace, it was running on Polygon's Amoy testnet for internal and invited testers. On 7 August we announced the rule meant to sit beside it, soul bounding. To use a Playermon NFT in the game, a player binds it to their game account. Unbinding is allowed, at a cost that decreases over time.
The problem breeding creates
Breeding makes new Playermons out of existing ones. That is the point of it: players can develop stronger creatures, and the collection grows through play rather than through another sale. It also means every bred Playermon is another NFT that could be sold. If new Playermons flow straight onto the market, the people who already own them, some since 2021, watch the supply they bought into keep growing. Our announcement named the risk directly: a potential decline in the value of Playermon NFTs.
There was a second problem, specific to competition. The announcement said binding was meant to keep play balanced, particularly in the Anchorland tournament, by preventing the repeated use of the same powerful NFTs to dominate matches. An NFT can move between wallets in a single transaction. Without binding, one strong Playermon could pass from account to account, and a leaderboard would measure who had borrowed it that week rather than how each player had built their team.
What binding does
Binding ties a Playermon to the account that plays with it. Each account's team then belongs to that account, and moving a Playermon elsewhere becomes a decision with a cost rather than a free transfer. Playermons in use stay with the players using them, and the ones that go back to the market are the ones their owners chose to release.
The falling unbinding cost is the part I find most useful as design, because it separates two behaviours that look the same on-chain. A player who has played with a Playermon for a long time and decides to sell it pays little to release it. Someone who binds a Playermon for one tournament and wants to move it straight on pays the most. Time becomes the price of commitment, and the people actually playing are the ones who pay least for it. The announcement did not publish the figures. They are better set from what testing shows than guessed in advance.
Not quite a soulbound token
The name borrows from an idea already in circulation. In January 2022 Vitalik Buterin wrote about "soulbound" items, taking the World of Warcraft term for items that cannot be traded once picked up, and asked what non-transferable NFTs could be used to represent.
Ours is deliberately softer. A Playermon that could never be sold would stop being something a player owns in any meaningful sense and become an ordinary game item. A binding that can be undone at a price keeps ownership intact while slowing the churn. The trade is between two things players value: being able to leave, and knowing that the Playermons they hold are not undercut by a constant stream of others changing hands.
What it asks of owners
Binding is a restriction on owners, and it should be described as one. Part of how it supports the collection is by making fewer Playermons easy to sell at any given moment. That is a fair trade only if players know about it before it applies to them. The announcement came while breeding was still on the testnet, which is the right order: a rule that changes what people can do with something they bought should be published before it takes effect, with its reasons attached.
Two things will be worth watching once binding reaches players. The first is whether the unbinding cost falls quickly enough that a long-time player never feels trapped by a Playermon they no longer use. The second is whether tournament leaderboards begin to reflect players rather than whichever creatures were passed around most. Both are questions for real play, not for a testnet.
Breeding adds Playermons to the game. Binding is how we set out to make sure that adding them does not quietly take value from the people who already hold the ones that exist.