All field notes

DeFi · Retrospective

What stablecoin rules could change about how games price things

A collectible card with a blank price tag beside identical blue coins stacked on a closed book.
Concept illustration · AI-generated

On 17 June the US Senate passed the GENIUS Act, a framework for payment stablecoins, by 68 votes to 30. It goes to the House next. Earlier in the month, on 5 June, Circle, the issuer of USDC, listed on the New York Stock Exchange. Stablecoins are being written into law and into public markets at the same time.

I am not a lawyer, and nothing here is legal advice. I want to think through what clearer rules could change for blockchain games, as someone who made pricing decisions for one without them.

The choices we made

When the Playermon marketplace opened in December 2021, we priced NFTs in MATIC, Polygon's native token, rather than in our own token, PYM. The decision came after deliberation within the team, and it kept the market's unit of account separate from our own token.

MATIC was not a stable unit either, though. A seller who listed an item still carried the movements of the chain's native token between listing and sale. And in September 2024 Polygon began migrating MATIC to POL, a reminder that pricing in a chain's native token also ties a game to that chain's own decisions.

Stablecoins were in our economy, but on a different side of it. Our liquidity pools paired game tokens with USDT. In February 2024 we removed the SGEM-USDT pool and moved its rewards to the PYM and PYM-USDT pools. When PYM went to Solana in March 2024, its Raydium pool paired it with SOL. So a stablecoin was the quote side of a pool, never the unit an item was priced in.

What the Senate bill would require

As passed by the Senate, the bill would require payment stablecoins to be backed one to one by reserves in specified liquid assets, such as US dollars and short-term Treasury bills. Issuers would publish the make-up of their reserves every month, and they could not pay holders interest or yield. In the European Union, MiCA's rules for stablecoins have applied since 30 June 2024.

None of this is about games. But several parts of it reach games anyway.

What could change for games

Pricing in a stable unit becomes easier to defend. A seller who lists an item for a fixed dollar amount knows what they will receive. The item's price then says something about the item, not about the token it happens to be quoted in. When the reserves behind that dollar are published and supervised, a studio can explain the choice to players without asking them to trust the issuer on its word.

The issuer becomes part of your game. The large dollar stablecoins already let their issuers freeze an address. A marketplace contract that holds stablecoins in escrow, or a reward pool that pays them out, inherits that power. Regulation makes the power more accountable. It does not make it go away, and a studio has to design for the case where an address it depends on is frozen.

Rewards start to look like payments. A game that pays leaderboard rewards in a dollar stablecoin is, in effect, paying out dollars. Who is being paid, from which country, and on what terms are questions a studio should take to a lawyer before launch, not after. Paying rewards in an in-game currency keeps the reward inside the game's own rules, which is one reason a two-token design is attractive. It does not make the legal questions vanish.

Yield has to come from somewhere visible. If issuers cannot pay holders a return, then any return a game offers on stablecoin deposits is coming from the game's own economy: fees, new deposits or the studio's treasury. Players deserve to be told which.

A game token does not become stable by sitting next to one. Pairing PYM with USDT in a pool gave it a price in dollars. It did not give it dollar backing. Clearer rules for payment stablecoins make that difference easier to explain, and harder to blur in marketing.

What I would weigh now

If I were choosing a marketplace's unit of account today, I would separate three jobs that games tend to give to one token: the unit items are priced in, the currency players earn by playing, and the token holders use to vote. A regulated stablecoin is a reasonable candidate for the first job. It is a poor fit for the second, because it pulls every reward into the world of payments. It has nothing to do with the third.

I would also choose a stablecoin by the rules its issuer works under, not by which one happens to have the deepest pool on the chain that week.

The bill still has to pass the House. What has changed already is the question a studio can ask itself. It used to be whether a stable unit was worth the trouble. Now it is which jobs a stable unit should do in the game, and which it should stay out of.