All field notes

Leadership · Retrospective

What an industry association is for

A round table with chairs around it and a glass block at its centre.
Concept illustration · AI-generated

I have served in the Malaysia Blockchain Association since 2019. That work sits beside TriveAcademy, the blockchain education initiative I founded in 2018, and the two have often overlapped. On 18 July the GENIUS Act, a US federal framework for payment stablecoins, was signed into law. Rules for this industry are being written in many places at once, and it has made me think about what an association like ours is actually for.

My answer comes less from theory than from two pieces of work I helped start.

A lab for researchers

The first was the MaGIC × MBA Blockchain Researcher Lab, which we launched in October 2019 with MaGIC, the Malaysian Global Innovation and Creativity Centre. Its centrepiece was an exploration lab, where participants could try different cryptography algorithms and consensus mechanisms and run blockchain solutions of their own.

At the launch I described the programme's main objective as cultivating more blockchain professionals. I still think that was the right objective. An industry that wants to be taken seriously needs people who understand how its systems work, not only people who can talk about them.

A workshop with hands on keyboards

The second was hands-on teaching. On 9 December 2019 the association and TriveAcademy ran a four-hour hands-on lab at Alphacap Campus, which I led as Trivechain's lead developer. It worked through blockchain basics, consensus mechanisms, smart contracts and industry use cases as practical exercises. Each attendee's certificate of completion was recorded on Trivechain itself.

That detail mattered to me. The people in the room left with a record on a public chain that they could look up for themselves, which is a better introduction to what a blockchain stores than any description of one.

What I think an association is for

Those programmes, and the years since, have left me with a short list.

Teaching that people do. Someone who has made a transaction and found it again on a block explorer asks different questions from someone who has only seen a diagram. Lectures are cheap to run. Labs take preparation, machines and patience, which is exactly why an association should run them: few companies will do it for people who are not yet their customers.

A place to experiment that no single company owns. A company's lab serves its product. A lab run by an association can let participants compare consensus mechanisms without anyone selling them one. That neutrality is the main thing an association has that its members do not.

A room where builders and policymakers hear each other. Working with policymakers and regulators is one of the association's stated objectives. When a rule is drafted, someone has to explain what a requirement will mean for a node operator, a wallet provider or a development team of two people. Someone also has to carry the reasoning behind a rule back to members who were not in the room. At the 2019 launch, the association's president said that blockchain development needs strong government support. That support works best when the people asking for it can explain their systems plainly.

Continuity. Projects change. Trivechain, the chain I was leading development on when we ran that December lab, became a legacy chain in 2021 when its holders moved to a token on Binance Smart Chain, now BNB Chain. An association can keep what outlasts any single project: its programmes, its records and the working relationships between people who would otherwise only meet as competitors.

What it is not for

An association is not a seal of approval. Membership says that a company takes part, not that its token, product or claims have been checked, and nobody should present it otherwise. It is not a marketing channel for whichever member happens to hold a committee seat. And it should not be one company's lobby wearing an industry's name.

These limits matter more when the industry is under scrutiny. If an association lends its name loosely, it spends the trust that makes its other work possible, including the conversations with the people who write the rules.

The work I would still choose

None of this is glamorous. The researcher lab and the December workshop were small, and their effect is hard to measure. They are still the kind of work I would choose first: teach people to build, give them a neutral place to experiment, and make sure the people who write the rules have heard from the people who run the systems.