All field notes

Security · Retrospective

When wallets outlive their owners: the keys nobody inherits

A key resting on an envelope sealed in blue, beside a small vault.
Concept illustration · AI-generated

July was my first month as CEO of Gambit Custody, Gambit Group's digital-asset custody arm, on a fractional mandate, alongside independent advisory and architecture work. On 28 July I gave a keynote and joined a panel at RWA Gateway, a Malaysia Blockchain Week side event at The Westin, Kuala Lumpur. At Malaysia Blockchain Week 2026, at the World Trade Centre Kuala Lumpur on 29–30 July, I gave a keynote on the DFNS Institutional Stage, "When Wallets Outlive Their Owners: Custody, Trusts and the Keys Nobody Inherits", and sat on the panel "The Maturing Bitcoin Ecosystem: Infrastructure, Access and Institutional Demand".

What follows is the argument behind that keynote title, written as an essay. It describes the general problem, not how any particular custodian, including the one I lead, runs its operations.

A key has no next of kin

Before a blockchain moves an asset, it checks that the signature is valid for the key that controls it. It does not ask who signed, whether they are alive, or whether a court has named them executor. Signing authority and legal entitlement are two separate facts, and the chain only sees the first.

For most of an owner's life the two coincide, so the gap stays invisible. Death, incapacity or a plain disappearance pulls them apart, in one of three ways:

  • Nobody holds the key. The heirs are entitled and cannot sign. The assets stay at their address, visible to everyone and usable by no one.
  • The wrong person holds the key. Someone who finds a recovery phrase in a drawer can sign without being entitled, and the chain will accept the transaction.
  • The right person holds the key without knowing it. They have the paper or the device, but not the knowledge of what it controls or how to use it without exposing it.

One slide in my keynote carried a figure that is often repeated: about a fifth of all bitcoin is estimated to be lost. It traces back to Chainalysis, which in June 2020 counted roughly 3.7 million bitcoin as lost, on the basis that they had not moved for five years or more. That is an inference from inactivity, not a count of lost keys. The chain cannot tell a lost key from a patient holder, and that is most of the problem in one sentence.

Why a will is not enough on its own

A will says who is entitled. It cannot sign anything. Writing a recovery phrase into it hands control to everyone who reads the document before the estate is settled, which is rarely what the owner meant. Leaving the phrase out gives the executor a legal right and no technical means of using it.

A trust has the same gap at a different point. A trustee can be given clear instructions, but they only work if the trustee can actually exercise control of the keys, under conditions that the trust deed and the key arrangement both describe.

I am not a lawyer, and nothing here is legal advice. The point is structural: the legal document and the key arrangement each solve half of the problem, and neither can see the other.

What code can do, and what it cannot

Part of the gap can be closed on chain. Bitcoin script, for example, can give a second key the right to spend only after coins have stayed unmoved for a set number of blocks, using a relative timelock. The owner keeps sole control by moving the coins now and then. If they stop, the backup path opens.

That is useful, and it has limits. The owner has to remember to reset the clock. The backup key needs the same care as the original. And the timer measures inactivity, the same proxy as the lost-coin estimate, so it cannot tell a death from a long stay in hospital. Code can enforce a condition. It cannot read a death certificate.

Designing them together

The title names custody, trusts and keys together because I think they have to answer four questions together, not be bolted to each other afterwards:

  1. Who is entitled, and which document says so?
  2. Who, or which combination of people and devices, can sign?
  3. What evidence moves control from the owner to a successor, and who checks that evidence?
  4. What happens if one of those parties is unavailable too?

I met a version of this in May 2021, when we moved Trivechain holders to a BEP-20 token on Binance Smart Chain, as BNB Chain was then called. The bridge could only act for someone who could sign with the original key. For a holder whose key was gone, no amount of careful engineering on our side could help, because the protocol had nobody else to ask.

That is the habit I carried into this month's talks. Draw the people and the paperwork next to the keys. Then remove one person, and check two things: whether anyone can still sign, and whether the person who can is the one entitled to.